Stockdale Paradox: Stoicism Triumphs Over Adversity

R.R. Saum
3 min readApr 14, 2023

--

Plane on fire and smoking with James Stockdale in uniform, caption- Stockdale Paradox: Stoicism Triumphs Adversity
Photo: composite of images, deserttrends licensed from Yayimages, the others were created by a U.S. Navy sailor/employee during official duties, is a U.S. federal government work and thus public domain in the United States.

Beneath a blazing sky over the jungle in North Vietnam, September 9, 1965, unfolds. James Bond Stockdale, a U.S. Navy Wing Commander, and true hero, is trapped in a flaming A-4 Skyhawk. Enemy artillery fire brings down the aircraft, forcing the pilot to eject into hostile territory. As the earth rushes up to meet the parachuting pilot, a whispered revelation escapes the lips:

“Five years down there at least. Leaving the world of technology and entering the world of Epictetus.” ~James Bond Stockdale

In the enemy’s clutches, Stockdale battles the horrors in the “Hanoi Hilton.” Regular beatings over seven and a half years left him bruised and battered. Living in filth, he disfigures himself with a razor to avoid becoming enemy propaganda and even beats himself with a stool until his face is unrecognizable.

Denied fundamental rights and medical care, Stoicism becomes his lifeline, transforming anguish into a powerful testament to human resilience. He remained unbroken.

Stockdale’s life exemplifies the Stoic philosophy of Epictetus and focuses on problems in his control. Compliance and escape were undesirable options, so he created the “Back Us” code to anchor his fellow prisoners in discipline and unity, empowering them to withstand their captors and uphold their military honor. Each letter represents a tenet:

  • B: Be prepared to give only name, rank, service number, and date of birth.
  • A: Accept no favors from the enemy.
  • C: Code of conduct; you must remember it.
  • K: Keep faith with your fellow prisoners.
  • U: U.S. government must take every lawful means to secure your release.
  • S: Self-discipline and a positive attitude.

Years later, he reflects, “It was only when I lay there on the rotting prison straw that I sensed within myself the first stirrings of good … bless you, prison, for having been a part of my life.”

bless you, prison, for having been a part of my life.” ~James Bond Stockdale

Ungrounded blind faith led some to their death as they lost hope, emphasizing the importance of a vigilant and rooted mindset. Marcus Aurelius wrote, “The art of living is more like wrestling than dancing, inasmuch as it, too, demands a firm and watchful stance against any unexpected onset” (Meditations, Book 7, 61).

The Stockdale Paradox emerges from a crucible of suffering. The essence of the Paradox lies in the balance between accepting life’s harshest circumstances and retaining unwavering faith in a better tomorrow. We can apply this powerful principle by letting go of what is beyond our control.

Released as a prisoner of war during Operation Homecoming in 1973, Stockdale received the Medal of Honor in 1976. His legacy teaches us that even in the darkest times, we can maintain our dignity, stay true to our values, and never lose hope in adversity.

Stockdale died in 2005.

About Robert

I tackle complex problems, eliminate roadblocks that hold businesses back, and provide a fresh perspective. If you appreciate this post, here are 2 things you can do to support my work:

  1. Give this story CLAP
  2. SUBSCRIBE to get my articles in your inbox

References

  • Stockdale, J. B. (1995, April 18). Stockdale on Stoicism I: The Stoic Warrior’s Triad. Lecture presented to the student body of The Marine Amphibious Warfare School, Quantico, Virginia.
  • Marcus Aurelius. (2002). Meditations (G. Hays, Trans.). Penguin Classics. (Original work published around 180 AD).

--

--

R.R. Saum

Futurist | Helping future-proof companies to lead tomorrow's markets. Navigate the future with confidence: rrsaum@boundlessliving.org